This was a great and interesting futuristic episode.
I like how the episode was used to establish a lot of character development for Clara, through the Doctor trying to work out what makes her so special for him to have met her in three different times. This allowed me to see how Clara seemed to have a normal life, shown through the meeting of her parents Dave Oswald and Ellie Davenport, them playing in the park with her and the funeral of her mother, which were all observed by the Doctor. This allowed for a lot more depth in Clara's character and allowed for the story to become more stronger and empowered.
As the Doctor and Clara arrived for the Festival of Offerings, it felt like a really good 'first trip' story as the appearance of various new and strange aliens allowed for me to empathise with Clara's wonder and excitement. Meanwhile, the story also explored the importance of history and treasured memories and items, as these were used as currency on the planet. Clara was then able to take centre stage as she had to give up her mother's ring in order to save Merry Gejelh, known as the Queen of Years, and then when she used the leaf that caused her parents to met in order to defeat the awaking god that feed on history and precious memories. The idea that the creature was defeated by the potential of the what could have beens and the possible future that Clara's mum should have had, was an interesting aspect to explore.
Furthermore, I also liked the use and possible power of song and storytelling and how it is often used to comfort or unity people. Murray Gold's soundtrack really added to these aspects to make a big and strong episode. In addition, the use, look and filming of the Vigil did well to add a bit of a creepy sense to the story, giving it a good mix of light and shade throughout.
Matt Smith and Jenna-Louise Coleman were superb in showing the continuing chemistry between the Doctor and Clara and their further development. Guests stars Michael Dixon, Nicola Sian and Emilia Jones gave great performances and supported the main characters and development of the story in really good way.
You know, the Doctor could have avoided Clara giving away her Mother's ring in exchange for a moped if he only had some sort of machine capable of traveling through Time and Relative Dimensions in Space...
ReplyDeleteyeah, although you know the TARDIS, it probably would have landed days later
Deletenot NuWho TARDIS, he can pilot it exceedingly well... have seen him use at as little more than a hovercraft... consistency is all I ask... also not for the cool concept of the living sun to be spoiled by silly grinning
ReplyDeleteyeah, i suppose that was to give a human quality
Delete